Why holding the line under family pressure is the real work
7/13/202618 min
You've been ping-ponging between two impossible choices for years. Cut everyone off and become the cold one, the one who abandoned her family. Or keep everyone and keep losing yourself in every gathering. All or nothing. On or off. In or out. But your family isn't one thing. There's the parent who did the damage, the sibling who was also a kid in the house, the aunt who quietly saw you, the cousin you actually like. A blanket rule forces you to treat all of them the same. So you either lose the people who were never the problem, or you keep the one who was. This episode is for the woman who's exhausted from flipping the switch and ready to ask a different question. The question was never contact or no contact. The question is: safe or not safe? And you answer it one person at a time. Your body has been telling you the answer your whole life. It's time to listen.
Timestamps: 0:00 – Intro
2:30 – The False Binary: All or Nothing
6:15 – The In-Between People (The Real Problem)
9:45 – Why You Override Your Own Read
12:30 – The Paradox: Fairness to Everyone = Unfair to Yourself
15:45 – The Reframe: Safe or Not Safe
18:20 – It's Not About Judging Worth, It's About Assessing Safety
21:00 – Addressing the Guilt Directly
23:45 – Leadership = Trusting Your Body Over the Argument
26:15 – The Dimmer, Not the Light Switch
29:00 – Your One Thing: Run the Sort (The Exercise)
31:30 – Holding the Line Under Pressure
34:00 – The Closer Links:
Subscribe on YouTube
Listen on Apple Podcasts:
Listen on Spotify:
Follow Dorcy on Substack: @dorcypruter Join the email list:
@dorcypruter on all social media
Transcript preview
First 90 secondsDorcy Pruter· Host0:00
You've been handed two options, and you hate both of them. Option one, cut everyone off. Go no contact across the board and become, in the family story and in your own mind, the cold one, the one who abandoned her family, the one who couldn't forgive. Or option two, you keep everyone. You stay in contact. You keep showing up. You keep walking out every gathering with less of yourself than you walked in with, and you keep paying the family tax. And you've been ping-ponging between these two for years. And you go all the way out, and the guilt and the grief get unbearable. So you come all the way back in, and the self-erasure gets unbearable. So you go all the way out again, all or nothing, on or off, in or out, and you keep trying to solve the relationship problem with a light switch. And what makes it so hard is your family is not one thing. There's the parent who did the real damage, and then there's the sibling who was also a kid in the house. There's the aunt who quietly saw you, and there's the cousin you actually like. And the blanket rule, whichever one you pick, forces you to treat all of them the same. So you either lose the people who were never the problem, or you keep the person who was.