What if your horse could say no — and you actually let them? Elsa Sinclair Part 1

What if your horse could say no — and you actually let them?

In this episode of The Noelle Floyd Podcast, Noelle sits down with horsewoman Elsa Sinclair, creator of Freedom Based Training and the documentary Taming Wild, for a conversation that quietly takes apart almost everything you've been taught about control. Elsa spent a year with an untouched mustang named Myrnah using no halter, no rope, no treats, and no pressure — just the freedom for the horse to walk away at any moment. What she discovered became Freedom Based Training, a method built on choice and trust instead of domination.

You'll hear how a single question from a student — "do you think they had a choice?" — sent Elsa looking for a way of being with horses that felt like peace and harmony rather than power. You'll follow her from a lonely childhood on a spirited Appaloosa to the offer she couldn't refuse that finally pushed her to test her wild idea on camera.

Along the way, Elsa reframes the everyday tools of horsemanship in ways that land far beyond the barn. You'll learn why she refuses to promise her horse a calm, "Buddha" version of herself, and what it means to simply behave well in the moment instead. You'll sit with her definition of trust as the willingness to suspend judgment, her 80/20 rule for how often you're allowed to get it wrong, and the story of Ari — the aloof stallion who needed no one and forced her to rethink her whole method. And you'll reach the idea that reorders the rest: that in a healthy herd, awareness replaces dominance, because dominance only shows up when no one was paying attention in the first place.

This is a slow, generous conversation about training horses without force — and about what changes in you when you give another being a real choice. Whether you ride, train, or simply love horses, you'll come away looking at connection, consent, and leadership differently.

Elsa Sinclair is a lifelong horsewoman, behavior researcher, and filmmaker. Her year with Myrnah became the award-winning documentary Taming Wild and, more recently, a memoir of the same name, and her Freedom Based Training method is now taught to students around the world.

If this conversation moved you, follow The Noelle Floyd Podcast so you don't miss Part Two — and share it with someone whose horse has been trying to tell them something.

---

IN THIS EPISODE YOU'LL LEARN

• The single question from a student that made Elsa stop and ask whether horses actually choose to be ridden
• Why she trains with no halter, rope, or treats — and what the horse's freedom to walk away forces you to get right
• The reason she refuses to promise her horse a calm, composed version of herself, and what she does instead
• How she defines trust as "the willingness to suspend judgment," plus the 80/20 rule for how often you're allowed to get it wrong
• What Ari, the aloof stallion who needed no one, taught her about reaching a horse who isn't interested in you
• Why she calls it the slowest training method on Earth, and the honest reason it isn't for everyone
• The herd-dynamics reframe that replaces dominance with awareness

To find out more about Elsa Sinclair: website | instagram | facebook | patreon

---

CHAPTERS & TIMESTAMPS

[00:00] A surreal reunion and the wish list that started the road trip
[00:44] Elsa's origin story: Demi and "good buckers make good jumpers"
[05:51] The birth of Freedom Based Training: peace over domination
[09:02] The question that changed everything — do horses choose to be ridden?
[11:34] The offer she couldn't refuse, and a documentary called Taming Wild
[14:24] Training without tools: timing, curiosity, and day one with Myrnah
[18:35] Companionship as currency: matching, mirroring, and sensory association
[21:31] The promise she won't make: congruence over composure
[28:22] Showing up on a bad day, and what trust actually is
[34:32] Ari, the aloof stallion, and the 80/20 rule
[40:49] Why the slowest training method on Earth isn't for everyone
[47:00] Herd dynamics: replacing dominance with awareness

Episode Sponsored by Total Feeds

Our mission to provide quality nutrition to people and animals puts us in contact with all manner of interesting folks. Whether you're interested in our animal feed, or the people involved in the animal industry: you'll find it at Total Feeds!

Check out our line of Quality Animal Feeds here: https://totalfeeds.com

Interested in more from Noëlle?

Noëlle's writing again — head to her Substack for essays, observations, and the kind of thinking that doesn't fit in an episode. https://noellefloyd.substack.com

Every episode is also on YouTube, where the conversation continues in the comments. 

https://www.youtube.com/@noellefloyd_plus

And if you're ready to go deeper, NF+ is where the real work happens — masterclasses, curated content, and a community that takes horses seriously. https://noellefloydplus.com

You can also download the app - NF+ App

Thank you for your support!