Nottingham Attacks: A ‘CATASTROPHIC collapse of responsibility’
6/8/20261 hr 8 min
The Nottingham attacks shocked Britain and raised urgent questions about mental health services, public safety and institutional accountability.
In this special edition of The Fourcast, Jackie Long is joined by the families of those killed in the attacks, alongside mental health experts, campaigners and policymakers, to discuss the findings of the Nottingham Inquiry and what must change to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
Emma Webber, mother of Barnaby Webber; Dr Sanjoy Kumar, father of Grace O'Malley-Kumar; and James Coates, son of Ian Coates, reflect on their fight for answers and accountability. They are joined by former Care Minister Norman Lamb, Professor at the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London Dinesh Bhugra, and SANE Chief Executive Marjorie Wallace.
Can lessons finally be learned from Nottingham? Has enough changed since the attacks? And how do we balance compassionate mental health care with public safety?
Nottingham Police said they would consider any recommendations made. Nottingham Health Trust did not respond to a request for comment. The CPS said they were ‘fully engaging with the public inquiry’. During the inquiry, a representative from the University of Nottingham said that since Valdo Calocane had left the university, the university had “continued to refine and adapt its policies and processes, but any changes made have not been as a direct result of the attacks themselves.” The spokesperson added that: "The University does not take the view that any of the changes made would have had an impact on the devastating attacks which took place.” The Department of Health said that “whilst there has been significant investment in mental health services over the past ten years, demand has risen and outpaced the services available”, and acknowledged “a significant and ongoing rise in demand means there remains a substantial treatment gap”.
Clips
Transcript preview
First 90 secondsJackie Long· Host0:00
The inability for every single agency to just do the basics of their job properly has led to this catastrophe.
Marjorie Wallace· Guest0:07
We go on the side of the patient far too much, and we don't take the steps that we could to contain them.
Sanjoy Kumar· Guest0:15
I fundamentally think that the mental health system is quite broken.
James Coates· Guest0:20
There shouldn't be a budget- Agree ... put on public safety.
Marjorie Wallace· Guest0:23
Can't believe the number of calls we get of people who are saying, "We need to be somewhere safe. We're not safe with ourselves."
James Coates· Guest0:32
If you don't hold people to account, we will not get system change. This just cannot happen again. This should be the last inquiry.
Jackie Long· Host0:40
Grace O'Malley Kumar, Barnaby Webber, Ian Coates, their names instantly recognizable for the worst of reasons. Stabbed to death in Nottingham in 2023 by Valdo Calocane, a paranoid schizophrenic. He tried to kill three others that day, too. Calocane is currently serving an indefinite hospital order after pleading guilty to three counts of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, and three counts of attempted murder. It is one of those attacks which genuinely shocked the country, the brutality. Two young students, a loving grandfather. But as the public inquiry into what happened comes to an end, a report not due till next year, the shock now is that the sheer scale of failures across institutions charged with our safety

