Eating Disorders: Does Dieting Actually Make Them Worse? (Part 2)
5/7/202658 min
Can you tell if someone has an eating disorder just by looking at them? Dr. Elizabeth Wassenaar debunks the "healthy look" myth and explains why dieting is toxic to recovery. This episode explores the critical "Nine Truths" of eating disorders, the role of genetics, and why early intervention is vital for long-term health.
Find mental health and addiction treatment near you: https://recovery.com/
In this deep-dive, host Terry McGuire continues the conversation with Dr. Elizabeth Wassenaar, MD, a triple board-certified psychiatrist and the Regional Medical Director at Eating Recovery Center. Dr. Wassenaar leads clinical excellence in treating complex eating disorders and guides families toward sustainable healing.
We cover the nuances of Binge Eating Disorder (BED)—the most common yet underdiagnosed type—and ARFID (Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder), a different entity driven by sensory avoidance or fear rather than body image. Dr. Wassenaar also breaks down the four levels of care: Inpatient, Residential, Partial Hospitalization (PHP), and Intensive Outpatient (IOP), helping listeners understand how much containment and support is necessary for true recovery.
Whether you are a parent looking for signs, a professional seeking evidence-based insights, or someone struggling, this video provides a roadmap for navigating the "crafty" nature of these illnesses. Recovery is possible, but no one has to do it alone.
Chapters:
00:00 – Intro
01:10 – Can you tell if someone has an eating disorder by looking?
05:02 – Why families are allies, not the cause
06:40 – Is it just a phase? The crisis of adolescence
11:02 – The role of genetics vs. environment
16:32 – Understanding Anorexia, Bulimia, and Binge Eating Disorder
19:46 – What is ARFID? Disinterest and sensory avoidance
24:00 – Why "just eat" or "just stop" is dangerous advice
27:45 – Explaining levels of care: Inpatient to IOP
44:40 – How long does recovery actually take?
52:34 – Common eating disorder behaviors to look for
Questions the Video Answers:
- Can you look healthy and still have a severe eating disorder?
- Why is "you look healthier" a harmful comment?
- Do parents cause eating disorders in their children?
- Is an eating disorder a phase that teenagers grow out of?
- How does malnutrition affect long-term bone health?
- Are eating disorders genetic?
- What is the most common eating disorder?
- Can you have anorexia while in a larger body?
- What is Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID)?
- Why doesn't dieting work for binge eating disorder?
- What is the difference between inpatient and residential treatment?
- Why do people with eating disorders feel they aren't "sick enough"?
- How does social media affect eating disorder recovery?
- What are the common signs of purging besides vomiting?
- Where can I find reliable eating disorder treatment?
#EatingDisorderRecovery #BingeEatingDisorder #MentalHealthMatters
Clips
Transcript preview
First 90 secondsElizabeth Wassenaar· Guest0:00
We have this assumption that if you are losing weight, you are moving towards health.
Terri McGuire· Host0:05
Dr. Elizabeth Wassenaar is the regional medical director at Eating Recovery Center. A triple board certified psychiatrist, she leads clinical excellence in the treatment of eating disorders, guiding families and teams toward recovery and healing.
Elizabeth Wassenaar· Guest0:20
Never, ever, ever has an eating disorder gotten better with dieting. The thing that most people with an eating disorder are prescribed is actually the thing that toxically reinforces the eating disorder.
Terri McGuire· Host0:32
Welcome to Recoverable. I'm your host, Terri McGuire, and joining me again today is Dr. Wassenaar, and we are going to continue our discussion about eating disorders. Today, we're going to be focusing on treatment options and things that work to help someone, and the different types of eating disorders, in addition to a million other things that'll come up. Starting with, I found a list on the Academy for Eating Disorders, or AED, of nine truths about eating disorders, and I just pulled four of them, and I wonder if we can start there. The first is that many people with eating disorders look healthy, yet may be extremely ill.
Elizabeth Wassenaar· Guest1:09
Absolutely, and by the way, I love that paper, Nine Truths About Eating Disorders. I, I strongly recommend people find it. It's available for free online.
Terri McGuire· Host1:18
Yeah.
Elizabeth Wassenaar· Guest1:18
And so I think this picks up on a theme that we talked about last week, uh, that's so crucial, is that you can't tell if someone has an eating disorder by looking at them.
Terri McGuire· Host1:27
Mm-hmm.
Elizabeth Wassenaar· Guest1:27
Uh, eating disorders can happen to people