Belonging Without Conforming — The Path From Pseudo Self to Solid Self
6/16/202659 min
We all want two things that can seem at odds with each other: to be our own person and to belong. We want to stand apart from the crowd, but we also want to be connected to it. When that balance gets out of whack, we either lose ourselves in tribalism or drift into isolation.
My guest today says many of the problems in modern life stem from our inability to hold these two impulses in tension. His name is Luke Burgis, and he’s the author of The One and the 99: Forging Identity in the Age of Social Contagion. Today on the show, Luke explains how becoming a true individual can give you the strength to be a part of a community. We discuss the difference between a solid self and a pseudo self — and what role families and rites of passage can play in moving us toward one or the other — why modern politics feels like a dysfunctional family, the dangers of performative religion, and much more.
- Resources Related to the PodcastLuke’s previous appearances on the AoM podcast:
- Episode #714: Why Do We Want What We Want?
- Episode #910: Thick Desires, Political Atheism, and Living an Anti-Mimetic Life
- The True Believer by Eric Hoffer
- Education of a Wandering Man by Louis L’Amour
- AoM Podcast #1,025: The Life and Legacy of Louis L’Amour
- AoM article with L’Amour’s weekly to-do lists
- AoM article and podcast about C.S. Lewis’ The Abolition of Man and the idea of objective value
- The Courage to Be by Paul Tillich
- The Quest for Community by Robert Nisbet
- AoM Podcast #847: Overdoing Democracy
- AoM Podcast #1,010: How to Resist Group Anxiety and Become a Differentiated Self
- AoM Article: Becoming a Well-Differentiated Leader
- Dying Breed article: A New Kind of Monasticism — The Power of Community to Shape the Soul
- The Rule of St. Benedict
Connect With Luke Burgis
Timestamps
0:00 Introduction
0:54 Guest Intro: Luke Burgis & The One and the 99
4:48 The Parable of the Lost Sheep & the Book's Framework
10:17 Defining the Self (vs. Identity & Soul)
14:37 The Pseudo Self Explained
19:40 How to Develop a Solid Self
25:35 Louis L'Amour & Education for a Solid Self
28:18 Curiositas vs. Studiositas (Ordered vs. Disordered Knowledge)
44:30 Tribalism, Politics, & the Pseudo Self
45:08 How Undifferentiation Fuels Political Dysfunction
51:13 Religion, Performative Piety & the Digital World
54:15 What Monasteries Teach Us About Community & Solid Selves
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Clips
Transcript preview
First 90 secondsBrett McKay· Host0:01
One of the things I've learned after running AOM for nearly two decades is that the fun part is creating. Writing articles, recording podcasts, designing products, things like that. The less fun part is all the operational stuff that comes with selling those products online. And that's one reason we've used Shopify for the AOM store. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e-commerce in the US. It handles all the stuff you don't want to spend your day worrying about. Inventory, payments, analytics, shipping, returns, all in one place. What I like is that it scales with you. Whether you're selling your first product or managing an established store, Shopify gives you the tools to keep things running smoothly. They've even built in AI tools that can help with product descriptions, page headlines, and product photography. Plus, as a customer, you've probably seen that purple Shop Pay button. There's a reason why it's everywhere. It makes checkout incredibly easy, which means fewer abandoned carts and more completed sales. It's time to turn those what-ifs into reality with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com/manliness. That's shopify.com/manliness. That's shopify.com/manliness. Brett McKay here, and welcome to another edition of the AOM podcast, which since 2008 has featured conversations with the world's best authors, thinkers, and leaders that glean their edifying, life-improving insights without the fluff and filler. The AOM podcast is just one part of the McKay mission to help individuals practice timeless virtues through thought, word, and deed. Also be sure to explore our articles on artofmanliness.com. Read the deeper dives we do in our Substack newsletter at dyingbreed.net,